How do I avoid getting scammed when buying comics?

Updated October 2026 · How we answer

Research the Seller

On eBay, check feedback score and read recent comments, especially for comic sales. On forums or Facebook groups, look for established members with a history of positive transactions. Scammers often have new accounts or generic photos.

Ask for additional photos with a timestamp or specific angle. If the seller refuses or gets defensive, walk away. For high-value books, consider using a middleman service or an escrow service.

• Check feedback on eBay, HipComic, or collector forums.
• Look for sellers with many transactions and detailed reviews.
• Ask for photos of corners, spine, and centerfold.
• Be wary of sellers who only accept friends and family payments.

Use Safe Payment Methods

PayPal Goods and Services offers buyer protection; Friends and Family does not. Credit cards also provide chargeback rights. Avoid wire transfers, cryptocurrency, or gift cards, which are hard to reverse.

If buying through an auction house, they handle payment and guarantee authenticity. For private sales, consider using a third-party escrow service for expensive books. Never send cash.

• PayPal Goods and Services: protected.
• Credit card: chargeback option.
• Escrow: for deals over $500.
• Avoid: wire, crypto, gift cards, cash.

Inspect and Verify

For raw books, ask for high-resolution scans of the cover, corners, and interior pages. Scammers may use stock photos or hide restoration. If the book is slabbed, verify the certification number on the grading company's website (CGC, CBCS).

Check for restoration, trimming, or color touch, which lower value. If you're unsure, buy from a reputable dealer who offers a return policy. Meet in person for local deals at a police station or comic shop.

• Verify slab certification numbers online.
• Ask for interior page photos to check completeness.
• Look for signs of restoration: trimmed edges, color touch.
• Meet in safe public places for local sales.

From our shops